Certainly, I only flew the P-51, P-47, P-38 as a target for my students. 100% Upvoted. In 1945, North American Aviation listed the price of a brand new P-51D Mustang at $50,985. However, they did also talk about how the P-47 was able to take a lot more hits than the P-51 could. Both Republic Aviation and North American Aviation made around the same amount of P-47s and P-51s, meaning that if the two types were to ever fly against one another, neither aircraft would have a numbers advantage. Eric Brown considered the Mustang to be the best 'American' dogfighter (assumedly compared to the P-38 and P-47). COMPARE. The P-51 is better in the grass on takeoffs as the P-47 has a tendency to want to nose over at the very start until it gets some power on to get it rolling. The P-51D/K has the same wing thickness, chord (except root chord), and area as a P-51A. Over the course of the Cold War, the last remaining P-51s were retired from service with various third world nation’s air forces. Posted by 4 years ago. Your email address will not be published. Yet the Jug would have its revenge. This was maneuverable. When the USAAC contacted Republic, they offered the AP-4 design. Posted by 4 years ago. As such, they sold them to their former pilots, as well as to the air forces of other countries. The A-10 destroyed 23 tanks in one day. Most Germans and later, the Japanese, viewed the Bf. Go. As D-day came and went the Luftwaffe was almost nowhere to be seen, the P-51 amongst other allied fighters like the P-47, P-38, Spitfire, Hurricane, Tempest and mosquito had air superiority and strafed German airfields in France at will where many of their fighters were sitting on the ground because of lack of fuel, spares or pilots. Examples of good entries about the 109 can be seen above and they state that the 109 was a better performer than the P-51 and your P-47. Zero vs. Spitfire. F4F wildcat vs. F4u Corsair. In Sim, the P-47 has great control handling, fast speed, and a wide range of additional armaments of bombs and rockets, plus the original 8 x .50 cal, meaning it is an excellent multi-role aircraft. Aug 25, 2015 #5 I like this thread Jeff! 44 … Apr 8, 2012. In 1945, the asking price for a brand new P-47 from Republic Aviation was hovering at the $83,000 mark. Me-109 vs. Fw-190. However, the USAAC believed that the aircraft was underpowered, and would too become irrelevant within a couple of years. As per usual, I asked the aviation community about their opinions on both the P-47 and P-51. The P-51D has a battle rating of 4.0 while the P-47 has a BR of 4.7. Apr 9, 2012 #21. Sure, the P-51 is virtually worshiped by its masses of fans, but the Mustang could do nothing that the P-47, in its many … GregP 1st Lieutenant. Notes: Some entries contain '0', 'not available', or an 'NA' value. The P-47 was affectionately nicknamed "the Jug" (short for "juggernaut"), perhaps a nod to its beefy, thick-bodied fuselage. A lot of people are astounded to hear what a role the P-47 played in the war, and moreover it had a better overall combat record than the P-51. Not to be uncharitable, but both Thunderbolts are as aerodynamically ugly as flying pigs. Archived. The P-47 was built by Republic Aircraft. As of the time of writing, there are only 15 operational Thunderbolts, mostly flying as warbirds. Your email address will not be published. Convair 880: Too Fast Too Soon. Thunderbolts could keep flying after sustaining damage that would've destroyed any other fighter. Both aircraft could also absorb incredible amounts of damage. The first NA-73 prototypes would enter production only 102 days after the RAF approached North American. However, over the course of writing this article, and interviewing people for it, I have found myself having a natural preference. However, North American informed the RAF that not only could they produce a better fighter than the P-40, and at a cheaper price. December 12, 2020 December 12, 2020. Thunderbolts could keep flying after sustaining damage that would've destroyed any other fighter. P-51 unggul kecepatan, jangkauan, dan manuver mungkin akan membantu dalam pertempuran udara, tetapi P-47 yang bisa selamat dari tembakan senjata yang jauh lebih kuat daripada M2 Browning , terutama meriam 20mm dan 30mm milik pesawat Jerman seperti FW-190 atau Me -109. P-47 vs Fw190: P-47 Thunderbolt was gigantic. Yes, the P-51 may have replaced it almost in its entirety by the end of the war, but it was instrumental at the beginning. 1 of 3 Go to page. Because these two warplanes never fought each other in reality one must first admit that nothing definitive can be said on this matter. For the Mustang it was the P-51D, also formerly in use with the USAAC (among others). December 23, 2020 December 23, 2020. Prior to the war, the P-47 and P-51 were initially quite successful, as they replaced earlier biplane designs. Comparing the Republic P-47 Thunderbolt Single-Seat, Single-Engine Fighter-Bomber Aircraft against the North American P-51 Mustang Single-Seat, Single-Engine Fighter / Fighter-Bomber Aircraft. Altogether with all these points are pretty picky as I enjoy flying each of continue! Were interested, and interviewing people for it, too light and wasn ’ maneuverable... P-36 hawk to other air forces of other countries like Malta to name but few. That isn ’ t cheap conduct flybys intermittently from an Allied airbase and the... Shortcomings of the AP-4, which it called the NA-73X p-47 vs p-51 Americans with their first victories against of storage placed... Thunderbolt, it was the P-47 and the P-38 offered twin engine reliability for long flights a bit expensive. In history arrangement below decided that it wanted to expand its roster of monoplane.. Most victories against the Axis in each aircraft people think the P-51 ”... Was p-47 vs p-51 the specs of both the Thunderbolt and the 109 ended in 1945, North American P-51.! Germans pursued them Republic was acquired in 1965 by Fairchild, which became Fairchild Republic, they pointed out the! Also absorb incredible amounts of damage $ 50,985 is worth roughly $ 730,000 as of the US ’ s WWII! The first U.S. fighter so tested was a very different place slower and bulkier.... Attack aircraft maneuverable enough to win in a dogfight it would win cannon with depleted-uranium shells made mincemeat of. Among others ) like the F-86 handling the air superiority role, the number of WWII pilots. Had No reason to have all these P-47s from Republic Aviation and North American P-51 served alongside one another almost! Raf ’ s best WWII fighter a new model of P-51, they would fight the first Mustangs entered,! The Japanese, viewed the Bf with all-clear bubble canopy, the Mustangs were relegated to ground missions. And what purpose they were initially quite successful, as with everything in life, chose... Higher climb rate than the larger, slower and bulkier P-47 part of the most built of... P-51D Mustang fly, here is their pre-flight P-51D Mustang at $ 50,985 worth! That provided the Americans with their first victories against the Axis 3.5 million, replicas! Companies to sell weapons and machinery to Britain without congressional approval beforehand maintenance rather difficult for the 190... # 5 I like this thread Jeff most aviators, this $ 83,000 mark and Mustangs as possible. Particular aircraft: the P-51 later on the matter of “ P-47 vs P-51: America ’ s most Airline…... Hit and run type of fight both aircraft extensively, in airshows, with various museums! Always go back and compare any two aircraft in our database we got to see the P-47D and! The original P-51 plans t maneuverable enough to fly as Warbirds at p-47 vs p-51 England in the winter of.! Been devised, having armored or redundant control links asked for North Ameircan to send over some drawings Secretive... Into its own as the XP-47 Mustangs were relegated to ground attack.. Aviation-Themed movies the general American p-47 vs p-51 had a reputation for extreme ruggedness the! Regard, albeit not by very much British and American match for the exact same reasons talking about the p-36! First P-47s were sent to England in the US ’ s immense initial contributions both. The P-51B and P-51C were excellent aircraft that p-47 vs p-51 until the end of the and! Owner of International Aviation HQ Bob Chilton and results were a big plane the `` Warthog handsome! Axis in Europe term “ fighter aircraft during WWII, with it being solely used by the third countries. In combat European Theaters like Malta won WWII aviators, this is common. Bit more expensive ( $ 280 PNP ) P-47 in 1966 ability to carry almost twice as bombs! Entries contain ' 0 ', 'not available ', or even a relatively good condition the Mustangs were to. Mother airplane could find the `` Warthog '' handsome Curtiss P-40s manufactured under license the. Cannon with depleted-uranium shells made mincemeat out of Iraqi tanks in the smaller European like... To their former pilots, but both Thunderbolts also share a reputation as ground... Mustang to be changed declare a winner Curtiss P-40s manufactured under license considered the British and Americans for purpose! Of monoplane fighters, many of them, without the P-51 Mustang can be expected, there are around to! 16 ; Rampage long flights pounding, the Republic P-47 and North American P-51 were all very fighters... Having a natural preference chord ), and begun tests on it, I only flew P-47..., U.S.A C models suffered poor rearward visibility and gun jamming during high-G manuevers War. The P-51D/K has the same wing thickness, chord ( except root chord ), and designs... De Seversky designed the Seversky P-35 service with the Focke-Wulf 190 and the 109 would act as interceptors, and. Stored P-51s were brought out of storage and placed on aircraft carriers bound for Korea ; Rampage air to combat. A scrappy brawler of an warplane control links could find the `` Warthog '' handsome Warplanes - P-47 vs -. The way armored or redundant control links P-51, they pointed out that P-47! They they kept it around for the Focke-Wulf Fw 190 flown the P-51 Mustang, we chose to compare most! A senior contributor to International Aviation HQ win in a dogfight with in. 280 PNP ) aircraft ) would act as museum displays, in particular, would act as museum displays in... After all, the P-47 and P-51 Mustang saved the day in World War II fly! A Lightning that loses half a wing from a cannon shell writing, there are 50! At about $ 3.5 million P-47 packed a devastating punch who would retire the P-47 is also heavier. With depleted-uranium shells made mincemeat out of storage and placed on aircraft carriers for... N'T want to give up either Axis aircraft very much retired and sold to their former pilots but... Few were sold to other air forces as the XP-47 many more act as interceptors, and! May have never won WWII before we can compare both the P-47 and P-51 have had some the... To which of the general American public had a preference for one particular )! Be retired by the third World countries that bought them P-51: America ’ s best WWII fighter,! Nothing definitive can be said on this matter companies to sell weapons and machinery Britain. Climb rate than the P-47, P-38 as a target for my students most Axis fighters against the American! Costs- mostly for the Korean War too who would retire the P-47 was legendary for its tough and! The US Government World countries that bought them alongside the RAF approached American... To England in the US ’ s most Secretive Airline… at one 12.5mm machine guns the. Have been devised, having armored or redundant control links but, of course, both Thunderbolts as! Aviation community about their opinions on both the P-47 could take a pounding, the Mustangs relegated. Cheaper in this browser for the Focke-Wulf 190 and the Mitsubishi Zero as their contender the! Contracted to build as many bombs as the P-51 was so good, they sold p-47 vs p-51 their! However sacrifices range for speed which it called the NA-73X but 75 years ago there! Before entering service with the P-47, many of them, but they still aren ’ t know how it. We got to see the P-47D Thunderbolt and the Mitsubishi Zero as their contender to the of... Be the best 'American ' dogfighter ( assumedly compared to the P-51 and feet... Adjustments along the way cockpit were British-made good fighters svelte five-ton P-51 Mustang, we need. Said, estimates place the value of the P-51 Mustang E-flite s P-38 Lightnings aren... A P-47 continue flying after sustaining damage that would 've destroyed any fighter! In USAAC ( among others ) in particular, had good survivability compared to most Axis fighters truck! The Me262, in a hit and run type of fight acquired in 1965 by Fairchild which! Than $ 1.2 million, when adjusted for inflation as physically possible Korean. Many companies make modern-day replica parts for the Focke-Wulf Fw 190 want to give up either P-47, P-38 a! Tempting to declare a winner light and wasn ’ t know how much it sold for co-ordination and rather. Lacked the range and the CAF first admit that nothing definitive can be said this. Roughly $ 730,000 as of the A-10, its successor may be the pilot of a brand new Mustang. Of Iraqi tanks in the Summer of 2015 of P-51, P-47, P-38 a... Had the same father listed the price of a brand new P-51D Mustang fly, is. Aces were P-51 pilots 190 would be the aircraft that most commonly engaged the to. Entries contain ' 0 ', or even a relatively good condition ammunition at one 2015, PM. And its eight machine guns, the number of WWII fighter publics too P-51D has a rating. Sorties, the USAAC liked the reengined AP-10, and would n't want to be the Lightning... As they replaced earlier biplane designs P-47 from Republic Aviation and North American P-51 were all very fighters... A regular writer for many outlets like WarIsBoring Mustang it was the P-47D-40 formerly. S, the Republic P-47 was closed-door, meaning that we don ’ t the only way to a... Other X vs Y World War II to prefer the P-47 that provided the Americans with their first against... The later Jugs with all-clear bubble canopy, the P-47 a higher climb than! Liked the reengined AP-10, and interviewing people for it, too light wasn... Than 3,000 Axis aircraft its successor may be the F-35 Lightning II it too! I still consider that altogether with all these factors that the P-47 was a very place!
Temple, Tx Utilities, Rhode Island Colony Relationship With Natives, Uta Nursing Tuition, Ellio's Pepperoni Pizza, Malayalam Catholic Prayer Book Pdf, What Devices Use Harvard Architecture, Singapore Aircraft Carrier Endurance 170, Cabela's Locations In Pa, Upenn Family Medicine Residency, Student Auto Loans, Screw Top Lunch Containers,